Should I buy the Almay Eyeliner, or the Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner?

I want to change my eyeliner, but I don't know which one to use. Right now I'm using the Urban Decay 24/7 Eyeliner, and I do like it, but since it's so creamy, sometimes it can be a bit messy for me, and the one thing I HATE is that I have to keep sharpening it, since it's so creamy, it gets blunt after like 1-2 uses. So which one should I get, and why?